10.1 Mall of America: Dreamhouse
Mall of America:
The Dreamhouse in Bloomington
How a baseball stadium became a city under glass, a Northwoods became a retail landscape, and two papers by geographer Jon Goss turned a shopping trip into a lesson about space, memory, desire, and Minnesota.
By the end of this reading, you should be able to...
There is a small brass home plate set into the floor of Mall of America. It looks like a bit of decoration until you realize that it is not decoration at all. Stand there and you are standing where home plate stood at Metropolitan Stadium. The stadium is gone. The baseball diamond is gone. The parking lots that once filled on summer afternoons are gone. But the place has not quite allowed the old geography to disappear.
Instead, it has swallowed it.
That is a useful place to begin, because Mall of America is full of places that are somewhere else. There is Minnesota wilderness without mosquitoes, an aquarium without a lake, streets without weather, a transit station inside a retail complex, hotel lobbies attached to shopping corridors, a theme park beneath a glass roof, restaurants that promise journeys, shops that sell identities, and bits of a demolished stadium preserved like relics. It is not simply a building containing stores. It is a machine for making places, and then inviting us to move through them.
Before the mall, there was a ballpark
In 1956, Metropolitan Stadium opened in Bloomington, surrounded by the broad automobile landscape that was remaking the Twin Cities. The Twins arrived in 1961. The Vikings played there too. For two decades the site accumulated memories, traffic, hot dogs, cold October wind, home runs, defeats, and the ordinary rituals by which a large piece of concrete becomes a place. When both teams moved to the Metrodome in 1982, the stadium became an unusually valuable kind of emptiness: seventy-eight acres beside the airport and major highways, close to a growing suburban population.


Bloomington bought the stadium site and invited development proposals. Mall of America broke ground in 1989 and opened on August 11, 1992 with 330 stores and more than ten thousand workers reporting for that first day. The mall did not erase the stadium completely. This is an early example of placemaking through borrowed memory. It preserved home plate, the old football fifty-yard-line marker, and the famous red chair marking the height and location of Harmon Killebrew's long home run. Mall of America's tour page identifies those markers as part of the site story.
This is already a little strange. A commercial complex becomes more convincing by preserving fragments of the place it replaced. The new landscape borrows authenticity from the old one.
Southdale had already invented the trick
Minnesota had been experimenting with enclosed retail worlds for decades. Southdale Center opened in Edina in 1956 and became the famous prototype of the fully enclosed, climate-controlled regional shopping mall. The idea was not merely to put shops indoors. The mall was supposed to recover some of the social qualities Americans associated with old downtowns while accommodating the automobile landscape that was helping weaken those downtowns in the first place.


That contradiction fascinated geographer Jon Goss. In 1993, only months after Mall of America opened, he published The "Magic of the Mall". His subject was the modern shopping center in general, but the timing was perfect. The monster mall had arrived in Minnesota at the precise moment he was asking what malls actually do.
When the suburb stops being just a suburb
By the time Mall of America was being planned, another observer of American metropolitan life had already decided that the word suburb was becoming inadequate. Journalist Joel Garreau spent the late 1980s driving around places that were supposed to be peripheral and discovering that many of them were no longer merely bedroom communities. Offices had followed houses outward. Shopping had followed households. Hotels, restaurants, entertainment, corporate campuses, and airport-oriented development had followed the offices. The old center was still there, but it was no longer the only place where metropolitan life became dense.
Garreau gave these new concentrations a memorable name in his 1991 book Edge City: Life on the New Frontier: edge city. His definition was deliberately concrete. An edge city had roughly five million square feet or more of leasable office space, at least 600,000 square feet of retail, more jobs than bedrooms, a regional identity as a destination, and a landscape that had been nothing much like a city only about thirty years earlier. The exact thresholds are less important than the geographical reversal they describe: people no longer had to travel from suburb to downtown for most of the things that made a place urban. Work, shopping, entertainment, and travel could now gather at the edge.
Bloomington is a particularly useful Twin Cities example. The airport, I-494, office and hotel districts, Southdale and the southwest suburban corridor had already pulled metropolitan activity southward before Mall of America opened. Then the Mall arrived beside the airport and freeway system like an exclamation point. It was not the whole edge city by itself. It was the spectacular retail and entertainment heart of a much larger suburban concentration.


At what point does a suburb start behaving like a city?
Turn the five criteria on one at a time. The drawing is conceptual, but the logic is geographical: offices, retail, commuting, regional identity, and rapid transformation accumulate around the same suburban node.
Minneapolis
AIRPORT
RETAIL
Housing can spread outward without creating a second downtown. Garreau's point begins when several metropolitan functions start clustering together outside the traditional core.
0 of 5 tests active
A shopping center rarely wants to look like a shopping center
Goss's 1993 argument begins with a simple trick: retail space offers another reason for being there. Add the layers one at a time.
A building arranges stores so customers can reach them. Useful, but not magical. The interesting question begins when the building claims a social purpose beyond selling.
What changes when shopping space starts borrowing the visual language of a city?
The same site changes roles as its connections accumulate
This sourced locator keeps the larger geography on the page. It follows one former stadium site in relation to downtown Minneapolis, MSP, I-494, TH 77, and the later Blue Line.
Metropolitan Stadium drew people to Bloomington before the mall existed. Its airport and highway context later made the 78-acre site unusually valuable for redevelopment.
Evidence: Mall of America dates the teams' departure to 1982, and MNopedia records demolition in 1985 before redevelopment.
The mall needs an alibi
Goss's 1993 article argues that shopping centers are private spaces designed to circulate consumers and commodities efficiently, yet they cannot announce that purpose too loudly. A place that said, in effect, please remain here as long as possible so that you will spend more money would be painfully honest. Instead, the mall presents itself as somewhere to meet, wander, eat, celebrate, look at art, watch people, attend events, escape bad weather, entertain children, or simply be among other human beings.
Goss gives this commercial landscape three especially important spatial archetypes. It borrows public space, the idea of the square or street where strangers can mingle. It borrows the marketplace, with the romance of stalls, vendors, variety, and personal exchange. And it borrows the festival setting, filling space with entertainment, spectacle, color, movement, seasonal ritual, and crowds. These are not meaningless decorations. They make the mall feel like a place worth visiting even before anybody decides what to buy.
Yet the public square has an owner. The street closes when management says it closes. Performances are scheduled, security is present, and apparently spontaneous activity takes place inside carefully managed boundaries. Goss's point is not that nobody has fun or that every shopper is being hypnotized. It is subtler. The space has been designed so that pleasure, movement, sociability, and consumption reinforce one another.



A small decoder ring for two academic articles
These are not perfect translations, but they let us keep the ideas without pretending every student has already read Walter Benjamin, Foucault, Lefebvre, Bakhtin, Marx and Freud before lunch.
A private retail complex can look and feel like a downtown street, park, marketplace or civic square without actually being governed like one. Goss calls this kind of borrowed place-making a pseudoplace.
Ask: what does the borrowed setting encourage me to feel or do?
Then Goss went shopping
Six years later, Goss returned with a much stranger article. For Once-Upon-a-Time in the Commodity World, he spent ten days inside Mall of America. He visited every tenant, read displays and brochures, took almost a thousand photographs, talked informally with workers and visitors, met management and custodial staff, shopped, rode the hotel shuttle with exhausted customers, and spent hours exploring the mall's early web presence. The method sounds almost comic until you realize how geographical it is. Goss treated the mall as a landscape that could be read.
The 1999 article asks a different question from the 1993 one. The first paper asks how retail environments manufacture public space, marketplaces and festivals. The second asks what kind of world Mall of America manufactures. His answer is that the megamall is a collective dreamhouse shaped by a commodity aesthetic: a place where idealized versions of nature, childhood, history, travel, community and authenticity are brought indoors and attached to things that can be bought.
Minnesota enters the mall, minus the mosquitoes
Camp Snoopy was the perfect case. Here was a Northwoods assembled under a glass roof: thousands of plants, flowing water, artificial rocks, logging and mining references, Paul Bunyan, amusement rides, wildlife sounds, and a cartoon character created by a Minnesotan. It offered visitors an indoor Minnesota that was greener, warmer, cleaner and more obedient than the real one.


The important word is not fake. A fake forest is easy to mock. Goss is interested in why anybody wanted a forest there in the first place. Modern urban life separates many people from the natural settings they say they value, so a commercial landscape restores a safe and consumable version of nature. You can encounter the Northwoods and still be five minutes from a pretzel.
The same device works with history. Met Stadium survives through home plate and the Killebrew chair. Old-fashioned retail design borrows clocks, station architecture, pushcarts, craft imagery and antique objects. Childhood reappears in carousels, toys, oversized characters and family entertainment. Travel appears everywhere: themed districts, restaurants as destinations, luggage, signs, transit, hotels, attractions and souvenirs. The mall is selling goods, but it surrounds those goods with stories about where else you might be and who else you might become.
What does consumption borrow in order to feel meaningful?
Turn the themes on and off. The point is not that every mall uses every theme. It is that retail space can package desires that existed before the purchase.
Choose a theme. Goss asks what human wish is being borrowed and attached to the retail setting.
A rainforest next to a cash register
Goss loved contradictions because Mall of America was generous with them. Nature was everywhere in a building made possible by enormous amounts of construction, energy, transportation and consumption. The Rainforest Cafe offered a carefully engineered tropical fantasy inside suburban Minnesota. Aquarium displays encouraged concern for endangered species while leading visitors through a commercial attraction. Environmental language appeared beside merchandise. In Goss's reading, the contradiction is not an accidental embarrassment. It is part of the experience.

Goss calls this a form of nostalgia, but nostalgia here does not simply mean remembering something that really happened. It can be nostalgia for a world we imagine has been lost: closer communities, innocent childhood, unspoiled nature, handmade goods, old downtown streets, heroic travel, simple marketplaces. A shopping environment can then offer fragments of those worlds as experience.
The bear from Minnesota that came from Indonesia
Then Goss found a teddy bear.
It was being sold as a Minnesota souvenir. One tag wrapped the object in a Northwoods tale: lakes, wolves, pine trees, craft, home and regional authenticity. Then a much plainer label cut across that story. The same bear was linked to a Vermont company and manufactured in Indonesia. The contrast exposes a supply chain hidden behind the souvenir story.
There is nothing unusual about an imported stuffed animal. That is precisely why the example works. The mall does not have to hide the manufacturing geography. It only has to make the Minnesota story feel warmer, nearer and more memorable than the supply chain.
A Minnesota story can connect to a much larger geography
Goss read a late-1990s bear tag at Mall of America that named a Vermont company and said the bear was made in Indonesia. The graphic follows the places named on that tag.
Reading caution: This is not a reconstruction of a factory, seller, owner, or transport chain. It is a map of the place names Goss recorded on one souvenir tag, which is enough to unsettle the idea that the object has only one local story.
Turn a Minnesota bear back into a global commodity
Use the four stages to compare how the same object can be understood: as a local memory, a regional story, a company product, and part of a global network.

northwoods memory
The bear first appears as a Minnesota object because that is the story attached to the place of purchase.


Shopping becomes a trip
For Goss, one of Mall of America's great achievements was turning shopping into travel. The visitor moves bodily through escalators, corridors, rides, winding paths and themed districts, while simultaneously moving through chronotopes in imagination to Minnesota wilderness, European markets, tropical forests, childhood, the nineteenth century, the movies, or a future world. The purchase becomes a souvenir of the trip.



This is why the mall's location matters. Bloomington is beside MSP International Airport and major freeways. The Blue Line station later added direct rail access. Hotels became physically connected to the complex. The mall was never merely serving nearby households; it was deliberately becoming a destination within the tourist geography of Minnesota.
But is it real?
This is where Goss becomes more interesting than the standard critique of consumer culture. It would be easy to end by announcing that the mall is fake, shoppers are manipulated, and real community exists somewhere outside the building. Goss does not quite do that. He argues that the desires expressed inside the mall can be genuine even when they are commercially organized. People really do want public life. They really do value childhood, nature, memory, celebration, travel, beauty and shared experience. A commercial environment may exploit those desires, but it did not invent them.
The difficult question is what happens when access to those desires is repeatedly offered through consumption. If we want nature, buy an outdoors identity. If we want memory, buy a souvenir. If we want community, attend a commercial festival. If we want individuality, personalize an object. If we want travel, enter a themed destination. The mall does not simply sell products. It continually suggests that goods and experiences can carry pieces of a more meaningful life.
Goss's preferred position is therefore neither sneering nor surrender. It is a dialectical reading. Enjoy the spectacle, but learn to read it.
Four photographs. Four questions hiding in plain sight.
Click each image card to reveal what a cultural geographer might notice. Then try the same trick the next time you are in any mall, airport, casino, theme park or entertainment district.

Look for civic-looking space inside private property.

Look for landscape imagery borrowed from distant or idealized places.

Look for memories and symbols that make a commercial place feel rooted.

Look for participation, personalization and ritual.
Then the dream changed costumes
If we froze Mall of America in 1997, we would preserve the world Goss walked through: Camp Snoopy, UnderWater World, Rainforest Cafe, old retail concepts, themed districts, movie memorabilia, nature stores, science stores, and the first generation of web-era shopping culture. But malls are peculiar preservation machines because they preserve nostalgia by constantly renovating it.
The symbols change. Does the machine?


Current Mall of America reporting describes about 32 million annual visitors and more than 300 events each year. Nickelodeon Universe replaced Camp Snoopy in 2008, UnderWater World became SEA LIFE Minnesota, and the Blue Line reached the mall in 2004. The attractions change, while the place remains a destination shaped by tourism, access, spectacle, and private management.


The useful comparison is not a claim that the current mall is identical to Goss's late-1990s field site. It is an invitation to identify which attractions and images have changed, then ask whether destination retail, themed experience, tourism, and private management have changed with them.
How an academic geographer builds an argument
Goss's papers show how academic geography builds an argument: define a problem, position it in earlier theory, state a method, collect evidence, interpret a landscape, and explain what that interpretation means.
The subject looks ordinary, but that is precisely why it is useful. An academic journal article does not require a remote rainforest or a border war. Geography can begin with a familiar landscape. The mall becomes interesting precisely because it is familiar enough to disappear.
The edge city tries to remember downtown
Garreau helps explain the metropolitan function. Goss helps explain the cultural form. The automobile helped move people, jobs, and retail away from old downtowns until places such as Bloomington began performing some of the work of a second center. Then Mall of America rebuilt pieces of downtown indoors: pedestrian streets, squares, crowds, cafes, entertainment, transit, hotels, events, art, tourism, and recognizable landmarks. The same suburban system that helped disperse the old city began manufacturing a new kind of urbanity at the edge.
And now the story has bent again. The mall is connected to regional rail. It contains hotels and major attractions. It hosts events and tourism. Its preserved stadium markers make it a memory site. Its theme park sells nostalgia for the decades when the mall itself was young. What began as the ultimate suburban shopping center increasingly resembles the strange mixed-use destination that its marketing always claimed it was.
Which means that the most interesting thing Mall of America sells may not be America at all.
It may be the possibility of place.
What to carry forward
Useful vocabulary
Quick check: Can you read the dreamhouse?
Works Cited & Further Reading
Foundational Works for the Minnesota Reader
Hart, John Fraser, and Susy Svatek Ziegler. Landscapes of Minnesota: A Geography. Minnesota Historical Society Press, 2008.
Adams, John S., and Barbara J. VanDrasek. Minneapolis-St. Paul: People, Place, and Public Life. University of Minnesota Press, 1993.
Tester, John R. Minnesota's Natural Heritage: An Ecological Perspective. University of Minnesota Press, 1995.
Twin Cities Public Television and Bell Museum of Natural History. Minnesota: A History of the Land. Four-part documentary series, 2005.
Sources Used and Updates for This Reading
Garreau, Joel. Edge City: Life on the New Frontier. Doubleday, 1991.
Goss, Jon. "The 'Magic of the Mall': An Analysis of Form, Function, and Meaning in the Contemporary Retail Built Environment." Annals of the Association of American Geographers 83, no. 1 (1993): 18-47.
Goss, Jon. "Once-upon-a-Time in the Commodity World: An Unofficial Guide to Mall of America." Annals of the Association of American Geographers 89, no. 1 (1999): 45-75.
Mall of America. About Mall of America; Mall Tours; and Security and Mall Rules.
Minnesota Historical Society. Metropolitan Stadium, Bloomington; and Southdale Center.
Metro Transit. Airport and Mall of America connections; and Blue Line opening history, including December 4, 2004 completion to Mall of America.
City of Bloomington. South Loop District, a current municipal plan that describes the airport-adjacent transit and road context.
Visual Sources
Metropolitan Stadium, Southdale, Mall of America, Camp Snoopy, Nickelodeon Universe, transit, aquarium, hotel, and retail photographs are from Wikimedia Commons or DPLA-hosted collections. Individual captions identify photographers and licenses where supplied by the source. The two new map graphics are self-authored teaching schematics: the Twin Cities locator uses the official sources listed above; the bear-tag network maps only the place names quoted by Goss.
Comments
Post a Comment