13.1 Historic Preservation: Memory is in the Walls

Minnesota Cities | Historic Preservation

The Memory in the Walls

What Minneapolis lost when ordinary buildings became disposable

Stand at Seventh and Nicollet in 1960 and the first thing you notice is not a masterpiece. It is a crowd. Woolworth's, Kresge, banks, offices, shop signs, awnings, clocks, delivery doors, buses, pedestrians, and windows all press into the same frame. No single element commands the block. The block works because many things are allowed to happen at once.

Within a decade, most of that scene would be cleared for the IDS Center, one of the finest modern buildings in Minneapolis. The exchange was not simply a mistake. It was a bargain, and bargains are harder to judge because the gain can be real while the loss is real too.

1888-90Oneida rises; Metropolitan follows
1929Wesley and Kresge open
1961Metropolitan disappears
1966National preservation law
1972IDS opens; local ordinance
1986Wesley tower is cleared
2025The ordinary losses return to view
Learning objectives

By the end of this reading, you should be able to...

Explain why preservation can protect future options, not merely old appearances, through adaptive reuse and option value.
Use parcel size, entrances, rents, and ownership to explain the geographical idea of fine-grained urbanism.
Distinguish a preservation review process such as Section 106 from an automatic prohibition on demolition.
Evaluate an old building using architectural, social, street, reuse, replacement, and equity values rather than age or beauty alone.
Evidence lens: this reading begins with James Lileks's 2025 reconsideration of several lost Minneapolis buildings, then adds historic-preservation law, archival photographs, surviving comparison buildings, and urban-design concepts. The argument is deliberately not "old is good, new is bad." It asks what choices, memories, street functions, and future uses disappear when demolition becomes irreversible.

The Block Before the Icon

A city block is easy to mistake for a collection of objects. Look longer and it becomes a machine made from thresholds. Every door connects a private interior to a public street. Every upper floor adds another possible tenant. Every narrow storefront creates another chance for a business to begin, fail, change hands, or surprise the people who walk past it.

Urban designers call this pattern fine-grained urbanism. The phrase sounds technical, but the idea is ordinary. A block with ten buildings can contain ten owners, several rents, many entrances, and a variety of room sizes. A block with one enormous complex can offer impressive coordination and public space, but it concentrates decisions and usually reduces the number of independent edges touching the street.

Image comparison

One place, two ways of seeing

Switch between the crowded pre-IDS block and the new skyline that followed. The photographs were taken from different positions, so this is a comparison of urban scale, not a perfect before-and-after alignment.

Nicollet Avenue between Seventh and Eighth streets in 1960. The scene is valuable not because every building is exceptional, but because so many doors, uses, signs, and people occupy one block.

Archival block photograph: The Minnesota Star Tribune. IDS photograph: Roger Wollstadt, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0.

The IDS Center was not a blank slab dropped onto the city. Its Crystal Court created a remarkable interior public room, its skyway links reorganized pedestrian movement, and its tower gave Minneapolis a new visual center. Yet the project also illustrates the arithmetic of redevelopment: many small decisions were replaced by one large decision. The city gained an icon and lost a texture.

The purpose of a downtown is not merely to display buildings. It is to make room for encounters that no architect can schedule in advance.
Donald Emmerich, EPA DOCUMERICA, June 1973. Public domain, U.S. National Archives.
In 1973, the new IDS Center made the 1929 Foshay Tower look small. Time had already turned one former symbol of modernity into an older layer of the skyline.
Donald Emmerich, EPA DOCUMERICA, June 1973. Public domain, U.S. National Archives.
The central question: Historic preservation is not a contest in which the old always defeats the new. It asks whether a city has understood the full value of what it is about to make impossible.

The Wrecking Ball Knows Only One Tense

Construction is speculative. A new building is a claim about what the future will need. Demolition is different. It removes an option with perfect confidence. Once a structure is gone, every imagined reuse disappears with it.

This is the practical meaning of option value. An old building may be unfashionable, awkward, or underused today and still have value because tomorrow's residents may discover a use nobody currently sees. Adaptive reuse is the process that turns warehouses into housing, banks into restaurants, offices into hotels, and industrial spaces into museums.

The Metropolitan Building, completed in 1890, became Minneapolis's most famous preservation warning because its interior revealed what the exterior concealed. Behind the heavy stone walls was a vast light court ringed by iron balconies and filled from above by glass. Photographed just before demolition, it looked less like a dead structure than a building waiting for a century that had not yet arrived.

The Metropolitan Building, completed in 1890 and demolished beginning in 1961, became the emblem of Minneapolis urban-renewal loss.
The interior light court explains why the building's demolition became such a powerful cautionary tale. It also shows why photographs and measured records matter when a city is making an irreversible decision.

Yet a fixation on the Metropolitan can distort the lesson. Cities are not made only from buildings dramatic enough to become martyrs. The more difficult losses are often the structures nobody rallies to save: the peculiar office block, the practical store, the ordinary brick tower, the shop with a restaurant remembered by one community and ignored by another.

1. The Federal Building: architecture as a crowded sentence

The Federal Building occupied the corner of Marquette Avenue and Third Street. The Metropolitan Building rises behind it at left.
Dwight W. Miller / The Minnesota Star Tribune, published by The Minnesota Star Tribune in Lileks's 2025 retrospective.

Completed in 1889, the old Federal Building held the post office, federal offices, and the U.S. District Court. Its architecture was less a pure style than a committee meeting: Roman arches, Greek columns, French roofs, towers, and ornament piled into one civic statement.

It was easy to call the building ungainly because taste had moved on. But cities need visual accents as well as masterpieces. A strange building helps people describe a corner, remember an errand, or recognize the route home. Its possible future might have been a hotel, a museum, or something less grand but equally useful. The point is not that any one reuse was certain. The point is that demolition made all of them impossible.

A city's vocabulary does not improve when every awkward word is deleted. Sometimes the odd word is the one that gives the sentence its voice.

2. The Oneida Building: a demolition in two acts

Long & Kees completed the seven-story Oneida Building in 1888. It was narrow, vertical, and confident, a stone slice standing at Fourth Street and Marquette Avenue. By the 1940s, it had lost prestige and tenants. Instead of removing it at once, owners cut it down to two stories. The surviving base became a platform for signs until the remainder finally vanished.

Architectural subtraction

Seven stories, then two

Switch between the Oneida at full height and the truncated remnant that followed.

At full height, the Oneida was a narrow but forceful corner building. Its vertical proportions and repeated arches gave the street a shape that the two-story remnant could not preserve.

Both archival photographs: The Minnesota Star Tribune, published by The Minnesota Star Tribune in Lileks's 2025 retrospective.

The Oneida also held social history that architectural rankings miss. Among its tenants was Yuen Faung Low, an early Asian restaurant in Minneapolis. A building is not only a facade. It is an address at which people work, eat, organize, meet, and become part of the city. When the address disappears, the history becomes harder to locate in physical space.

3. Wesley Temple: the ordinary building that changed categories

The Wesley Temple office tower opened in 1929 as the first phase of a much larger religious and commercial complex.
The Minnesota Star Tribune, published by The Minnesota Star Tribune in Lileks's 2025 retrospective.
The older 1891 church survives. The twelve-story office tower beside it was cleared in 1986 for the convention-center project.
McGhiever, 2021, CC BY-SA 4.0.

The Wesley tower was born from a 1920s idea called the skyscraper church. Rent from offices and a hotel would help support a large downtown congregation. The first twelve-story phase opened in September 1929. Then the stock market crashed, the grand complex stopped growing, and the part that had been built was left looking less like a visionary fragment than an ordinary office block.

That change in reputation matters. Ordinary is not a permanent architectural category. It is often what people call a building during the years between being new and becoming old enough to seem distinctive. The Wesley tower's brick and terra-cotta surfaces, dismissed in the 1980s as unremarkable, would have stood apart in a later downtown dominated by reflective glass. It might have become housing, a hotel, or offices again. Instead, it became a reminder that age can produce value only if a building survives long enough to acquire it.

4. Kresge, Woolworth, and the ecology of retail

The Kresge Building opened in 1929 with retail on two floors and offices above. Across the block, Woolworth's presented a larger Art Deco face to Nicollet Avenue. Nearby were Bernard's, Lerner's, banks, and smaller commercial buildings. The architecture ranged from plain to stylish, but the deeper pattern was mixed use. Shopping, work, signs, offices, services, and street life occupied different levels of the same block.

Kresge joined broad ground-floor windows to several upper stories of offices.
Roy Swan / The Minnesota Star Tribune, April 1960.
Woolworth's gave the corner Art Deco height, windows, and a large retail entrance.
The Minnesota Star Tribune, published by The Minnesota Star Tribune in Lileks's 2025 retrospective.
First Federal's giant clock made a plain modern facade useful to anyone walking past.
The Minnesota Star Tribune, published by The Minnesota Star Tribune in Lileks's 2025 retrospective.

A clock seems like a minor detail until it becomes part of how thousands of people orient themselves. A restaurant seems minor until it is one of the few addresses where a community's history remains visible. A shop window seems minor until the block loses enough of them that pedestrians no longer have reasons to slow down. Urban life is often made from small features whose value appears only after they are gone.

A public clock is not a great building, but it can become part of the shared equipment of city life.
The replacement was not empty of urban value. The Crystal Court created a new gathering space of a very different kind.
The hardest preservation argument is not about choosing between a beautiful old building and an ugly new one. It is about recognizing that a great new building can still erase a valuable old pattern.

Interactive: How Fine Is the Grain?

Parcel size influences what a block can do. Many small parcels can support varied ownership, rents, entrances, and uses. A consolidated parcel can make a large coordinated project possible. Move the slider to see a conceptual block change. This is a teaching model, not a numerical reconstruction of Seventh and Nicollet.

Urban geography lab

From many doors to one decision

The model does not declare one arrangement universally best. It makes the trade-offs visible.

Street edgeMany entrances and frequent visual change
Space and rentMany sizes can support varied tenants
RedevelopmentHarder to coordinate one very large project

The model isolates one variable. Real blocks also depend on building condition, ownership, zoning, financing, transit, public space, and the people who use them.

The Young-Quinlan Building offers a surviving comparison: an older commercial structure can hold retail, offices, and new uses without surrendering its presence on the street.
Elkman, 2012, CC BY-SA 3.0.
City Center, opened in the early 1980s, represents the opposite scale: a large mixed-use project assembled and managed as a single complex.
Tony Webster, 2018, CC BY 2.0.

Neither photograph supplies a universal formula. A fine-grained block can be neglected, unsafe, or economically weak. A large complex can create excellent interior space and concentrate investment where it is badly needed. The geographic lesson is that scale changes power. It changes how many owners must agree, how many tenants can fit, how often doors appear, and how easily one decision can transform an entire block.

When Preservation Acquired a Vocabulary

During the great clearance campaigns of the 1950s and early 1960s, many American cities possessed enthusiasm for renewal but few durable procedures for asking what might be lost. Public anger over demolitions gradually produced a new legal language. The National Historic Preservation Act arrived in 1966. Minneapolis created a local preservation ordinance in 1972. By then the Metropolitan Building was already gone and demolition for the IDS project had begun.

The new rules did not freeze the city. Preservation law is a process for identifying significance, documenting places, reviewing effects, and considering alternatives. Federal Section 106 review, for example, requires consideration when a federal action, permit, or funding source is involved. It does not automatically command that every historic building remain.

Preservation clock

What could the city know, and what tools did it have?

Select a year to see how the architectural landscape and preservation system changed together.

Building age

The city is building the future that later generations will debate

The Oneida rises in 1888, and the Metropolitan follows in 1890. Nobody calls them historic. They are speculative commercial projects using the styles, technologies, and ambitions of their own moment.

Preservation changed the timing of the argument. Instead of waiting until a building became a photograph, cities could hold the debate while alternatives still existed. That did not remove conflict. It made conflict visible before the wrecking ball settled it.

There is another complication. Official preservation systems tend to recognize what has already been researched, nominated, and defended. Buildings connected to powerful institutions are often easier to document than the modest places where immigrants, workers, small businesses, and minority communities made urban life. A complete preservation geography must therefore ask not only which architecture is beautiful, but whose history has been given an address.

2026 update: Minneapolis still uses the preservation ordinance created in 1972, but Chapter 599 was comprehensively revised in 2025 and the new rules took effect January 1, 2026. The City says the program now includes more than 195 local landmarks and 20 historic districts. Current preservation work also includes an African American Historic & Cultural Context study, which fits the problem raised above: preservation becomes more complete when it looks for social history before the building associated with it disappears.

What Should a City Save?

There is no honest rule that says every old building must survive. Some structures are dangerous beyond practical repair. Some no longer fit any plausible use. Some replacements provide overwhelming public benefit. The problem is that decisions are often made while one side of the ledger is described in precise dollars and the other is reduced to sentiment.

Decision room

Change the building, change the questions

Choose a scenario. The panel does not give a verdict; it identifies the questions a responsible preservation debate should ask.

Adaptive reuse

Vacancy is a condition, not a destiny

Ask why the building is empty, whether its floor plates and structure can support a new use, what public assistance would be required, and whether temporary vacancy is being mistaken for permanent worthlessness.

Architectural value

Is the building rare, skillfully designed, or representative of a period that has largely disappeared?

Social value

Which communities, businesses, events, or everyday experiences are tied to the address?

Street value

Does the building provide doors, windows, small spaces, shelter, landmarks, or continuity along the sidewalk?

Reuse value

Can the structure accept housing, offices, retail, cultural space, or a use not yet imagined?

Replacement value

Is the proposed project real, financed, and demonstrably better, or is demolition being requested for an uncertain promise?

Equity value

Who gains from the change, who carries its costs, and whose history is easiest to overlook?

The most useful preservation question may be the simplest: what will this place no longer be able to do after demolition? That question shifts attention from appearance alone to capacity. It asks what kinds of people, rents, businesses, memories, and future adaptations the existing building makes possible.

The city is experienced at human height: a bench, a lunch, a shop window, a clock, a familiar corner. Those ordinary settings are part of what preservation protects.
The new city becomes the old city faster than anyone expects. IDS itself is now a historic layer in the skyline it once transformed.
How to read a city: Look at the celebrated tower, then look beside it. Count the doors. Notice the upper floors. Ask what a plain building permits, who uses it, and whether its replacement will preserve any of that capacity. A city is an archive still in use.

The choice is not between living in the past and building the future. Cities must change or they become museums. The real choice is whether change leaves enough evidence, variety, and adaptable space for the next generation to inherit more than a series of isolated monuments.

Main Ideas and Geographic Thinking

Preservation is about options

Demolition ends every future reuse. Keeping a structure can preserve choices even when its next purpose is uncertain.

Ordinary buildings form systems

Small parcels, mixed uses, frequent doors, varied rents, and many owners can matter more to street life than any single facade.

Great gains can include real losses

The IDS Center is a major architectural achievement, but its success does not erase the value of the fine-grained block it replaced.

Preservation law changes timing

Processes such as Section 106 and local review force questions to be asked while alternatives still exist; they do not guarantee that every building survives.

Social memory needs addresses

Restaurants, shops, congregations, workplaces, and ordinary buildings can carry histories that architectural rankings overlook.

The new city becomes old too

IDS itself is now more than half a century old. Every successful new project immediately starts becoming part of the inherited city future planners will have to judge.

Questions for geographic thinking

  1. How does parcel size change the number of owners, entrances, tenants, and decisions present on a city block?
  2. Why can an ordinary building gain value simply by surviving while surrounding architecture changes?
  3. What kinds of social history are most likely to be missed when preservation focuses only on famous architecture?
  4. How can a city compare the measurable financial value of a new project with the less measurable value of memory, adaptability, and street life?
  5. Choose a familiar block in your community. Which building would be hardest to replace, even if it is not the most beautiful?

Glossary

Adaptive reuse
Converting an older building to a new purpose while retaining much of its structure and character.
Fine-grained urbanism
A pattern of many small parcels, buildings, entrances, owners, and uses along a street or block.
Historic district
An area recognized for the combined historical or architectural importance of a group of buildings, streets, landscapes, or sites.
Historic landmark
A building, site, structure, object, or other property formally recognized for historical, architectural, cultural, engineering, or related significance.
Option value
The value of keeping future choices open when the best long-term use is not yet known.
Parcel
A legally defined piece of land under one ownership or tax description; parcel size strongly affects redevelopment and urban grain.
Preservation review
A formal process for evaluating changes to designated properties or determining whether a property may qualify for protection.
Public realm
The streets, sidewalks, plazas, parks, transit spaces, and other settings where public urban life takes place.
Section 106
A federal review process requiring agencies to consider effects on listed or eligible historic properties before covered federal undertakings proceed.
Urban renewal
Programs, especially prominent after World War II, that cleared and redeveloped areas labeled obsolete or blighted, often at great social and architectural cost.

Check your understanding

1. How does the reading characterize the IDS Center?

2. What is a central feature of fine-grained urbanism?

3. Why is the Oneida Building described as a demolition in two acts?

4. What interrupted the larger Wesley Temple complex?

5. What does Section 106 do?

6. Why can a plain building be worth preserving?

Works Cited & Further Reading

  • Foundational Works for the Minnesota Reader: Hart, John Fraser, and Susy Svatek Ziegler. Landscapes of Minnesota: A Geography. Minnesota Historical Society Press, 2008.
  • Adams, John S., and Barbara J. VanDrasek. Minneapolis-St. Paul: People, Place, and Public Life. University of Minnesota Press, 1993.
  • Tester, John R. Minnesota's Natural Heritage: An Ecological Perspective. University of Minnesota Press, 1995.
  • Twin Cities Public Television and Bell Museum of Natural History. Minnesota: A History of the Land. Four-part documentary series, 2005.
  • Lileks, James. "People Said These Minneapolis Buildings Weren't Worth Saving, but They Were Wrong." Minnesota Star Tribune, April 5, 2025. Principal contemporary source for the Federal Building, Oneida, Wesley Temple, Kresge, Woolworth, and First Federal examples.
  • Minnesota Historical Society / MNopedia. "Three Thousand Years of Building in Minnesota." Used for Minneapolis urban-renewal and Metropolitan Building preservation context.
  • National Park Service. National Historic Preservation Act and Section 106 Compliance Program.
  • City of Minneapolis. Chapter 599 Heritage Preservation Ordinance updates; and Preservation Review. The revised Chapter 599 took effect January 1, 2026.
  • IDS Center. Official timeline. Demolition of the block began in 1969; tenants moved into the tower and the Crystal Court opened in 1972.
  • Visual sources: Historic American Buildings Survey and Library of Congress; EPA DOCUMERICA / U.S. National Archives; Wikimedia Commons images credited beneath each figure; and Minnesota Star Tribune archival images reproduced by URL with attribution to the newspaper and photographers where identified.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

1.1 Minnesota: A History of the Land 1 Ordering the Land

2.1 Minnesota A History of the Land 2 When Minnesota Began Spending Its Inheritance

1.2 Minnesota: A Pollen Grain, a Prairie Fire, and a Surveyor’s Chain